History for Main/SelfMadeLie - TV Tropes (2024)

Is there an issue? Send a MessageReason:

Spelling/grammar fix(es)

Changed line(s) 8,9 (click to see context) from:

While some people pretend to have come from a privileged background due to shame over their middle or lower class roots, there are those of a richer background who do the opposite. The Self-Made Lie is when someone who is known for having fought their way to the top and earned their wealth, power and position in society is shown to have had advantages that were unknown to others. At the most innocent, they simply got lucky, had a leg-up that they kept secret or didn't even know about (inherited wealth, favors from a friend); at the most insidious, their success is due to exploiting others or [[StealingTheCredit cheating them out of their deserved credit.]] This can lead to StolenCreditBackfire once the self-made liar finds themselves in a position where they can't lie their way out of a situation. This can also result in a BrokenPedestal and is common in stories about a LiarRevealed. Sometimes, the beneficiary of the lie [[BelievingTheirOwnLies may actually delude themselves into thinking their accomplishments are due solely to their own efforts]].

While some people pretend to have come from a privileged background due to shame over their middle or lower class roots, there are those of a richer background who do the opposite. The Self-Made Lie is when someone who is known for having fought their way to the top and earned their wealth, power and position in society is shown to have had advantages that were unknown to others. At the most innocent, they simply got lucky, had a leg-up that they kept secret or didn't even know about (inherited wealth, favors from a friend); at the most insidious, their success is due to exploiting others or [[StealingTheCredit cheating them out of their deserved credit.]] This can lead to StolenCreditBackfire once the self-made liar finds themselves in a position where they can't lie their way out of a situation. This can also result in a BrokenPedestal and is common in stories about a LiarRevealed. Sometimes, the beneficiary of the lie [[BelievingTheirOwnLies may actually delude themselves into thinking their accomplishments are due solely to their own efforts]].

Changed line(s) 14,16 (click to see context) from:

\nCompare MockMillionaire, MilesGloriosus, PhonyVeteran and FakeUltimateHero. See BasedOnAGreatBigLie for cases where a purportedly real event that brings someone fame and fortune turns out to be fictitious. See also HardWorkFallacy, which is the belief that anyone successful has worked hard for it.

Changed line(s) 31,32 (click to see context) from:

* ''ComicBook/DisneyDucksComicUniverse'': Scrooge [=McDuck=] is typically depicted as a SelfMadeMan who started with nothing and earned his wealth in the Klondike Gold Rush. He often claims that he got wealthy by being "smarter than the smarties and tougher than the toughies, and [he] made it square!" (meaning fairly). [[DependingOnTheWriter However, some stories about his past have depicted him in a shadier light, earning part of his wealth as a con-artist, a smuggler, a robber baron, etc]]. As early as ComicBook/BackToTheKlondike (1953), Scrooge revealed that he never paid the taxes required for his original gold mine, and several Italian stories featured a number of Scrooge's ex-partners, who he cheated out of their share of the wealth.
* Franchise/ArchieComics: Played for laughs in an old story about the multi-millionaire Hiram Lodge. He tries to impress Archie Andrews (his daughter's boyfriend) by explaining that he started out impoverished, and got ahead in life with hard work and by depending on his wits. He lists some low-paying jobs which he had in his childhood and teenage years, and the effort he placed on them. Then Veronica (Hiram's daughter) innoccently reveals that Hiram became wealthy in the old-fashioned way, by courting and marrying a wealthy heiress. The previously intimidated Archie mocks Hiram's story of success.

* ''ComicBook/DisneyDucksComicUniverse'': Scrooge [=McDuck=] is typically depicted as a SelfMadeMan who started with nothing and earned his wealth in the Klondike Gold Rush. He often claims that he got wealthy by being "smarter than the smarties and tougher than the toughies, and [he] made it square!" (meaning fairly). [[DependingOnTheWriter However, some stories about his past have depicted him in a shadier light, earning part of his wealth as a con-artist, a smuggler, a robber baron, etc]]. As early as ComicBook/BackToTheKlondike (1953), Scrooge revealed that he never paid the taxes required for his original gold mine, and several Italian stories featured a number of Scrooge's ex-partners, who he cheated out of their share of the wealth.
* Franchise/ArchieComics: Played for laughs in an old story about the multi-millionaire Hiram Lodge. He tries to impress Archie Andrews (his daughter's boyfriend) by explaining that he started out impoverished, and got ahead in life with hard work and by depending on his wits. He lists some low-paying jobs which he had in his childhood and teenage years, and the effort he placed on them. Then Veronica (Hiram's daughter) innoccently reveals that Hiram became wealthy in the old-fashioned way, by courting and marrying a wealthy heiress. The previously intimidated Archie mocks Hiram's story of success.

Changed line(s) 44 (click to see context) from:

* ''Film/TheWolfOfWallStreet'': Jordan Belfort presents himself as proof that hard work and ambition can get you the American Dream. However, [[UnreliableNarrator he leaves out the part about being a white collar criminal whose accomplishments are almost entirely through illegal means.]]

* ''Film/TheWolfOfWallStreet'': Jordan Belfort presents himself as proof that hard work and ambition can get you the American Dream. However, [[UnreliableNarrator he leaves out the part about being a white collar criminal whose accomplishments are almost entirely through illegal means.]]

Changed line(s) 48,49 (click to see context) from:

* ''Agent Z and The Penguin From Mars'': Ben's wealthy new neighbor Dennis Sidebottom claims to have gotten rich from betting money in a football pool and boasts about him getting to where he is through intelligence and hard work. However, the climax reveals that the Sidebottoms' money was actually stolen from an Australian casino. Even after being exposed as nothing but a common thief, Dennis still brags about being an hard worker.
* ''Literature/HarryPotterAndTheChamberOfSecrets'': Gilderoy Lockhart is a wizard celebrity who has written numerous books about his adventures defeating trolls, hags, werewolves, yetis and such. [[spoiler:All of his accomplishments were done by other wizards, [[LaserGuidedAmnesia whose memories of the events he erased while he took credit for their deeds]].]]

* ''Agent Z and The Penguin From Mars'': Ben's wealthy new neighbor Dennis Sidebottom claims to have gotten rich from betting money in a football pool and boasts about him getting to where he is through intelligence and hard work. However, the climax reveals that the Sidebottoms' money was actually stolen from an Australian casino. Even after being exposed as nothing but a common thief, Dennis still brags about being an hard worker.
* ''Literature/HarryPotterAndTheChamberOfSecrets'': Gilderoy Lockhart is a wizard celebrity who has written numerous books about his adventures defeating trolls, hags, werewolves, yetis and such. [[spoiler:All of his accomplishments were done by other wizards, [[LaserGuidedAmnesia whose memories of the events he erased while he took credit for their deeds]].]]

Changed line(s) 52 (click to see context) from:

* ''Literature/RebuildWorld'': To an outside viewer, Akira is a gifted prodigy who clawed his way up from being a slum rat to a hunter making massive amounts of cash. In truth, Akira is extremely reliant on [[VirtualSidekick Alpha]] in most situations and knows he's indebted to her for helping him survive one crisis after the other. While he does try to make it on his own merits, his bad luck frequently lands him situations he can't handle on his own.

* ''Literature/RebuildWorld'': To an outside viewer, Akira is a gifted prodigy who clawed his way up from being a slum rat to a hunter making massive amounts of cash. In truth, Akira is extremely reliant on [[VirtualSidekick Alpha]] in most situations and knows he's indebted to her for helping him survive one crisis after the other. While he does try to make it on his own merits, his bad luck frequently lands him situations he can't handle on his own.

Changed line(s) 57 (click to see context) from:

* ''Series/Castle2009'': In "Sucker Punch", the team meets a man named Johnny Vong who runs a get rich quick scheme and claims to have come from East Asia by boat. When the team tries to question him about the VictimOfTheWeek, they discover he is not in fact a foreigner, but a Califorian MIT-Graduate who got rich through his involvement in a drug smuggling ring.

* ''Series/Castle2009'': In "Sucker Punch", the team meets a man named Johnny Vong who runs a get rich quick scheme and claims to have come from East Asia by boat. When the team tries to question him about the VictimOfTheWeek, they discover he is not in fact a foreigner, but a Califorian MIT-Graduate who got rich through his involvement in a drug smuggling ring.

Changed line(s) 61 (click to see context) from:

* ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine'': The second season's opening trilogy of episodes features the character Li Nalas, whom the Bajoran people view as a war hero who killed a notorious Cardassian officer after a long struggle. The real story is that Nalas had a lucky shot and the corpse happened to fall on him. Nalas didn't even know who the Cardassian was until afterwards. Despite this, he became a legend and many victories were attributed to him. Eventually he had to run away to exile to get away from the hassles of his fame.

* ''Series/StarTrekDeepSpaceNine'': The second season's opening trilogy of episodes features the character Li Nalas, whom the Bajoran people view as a war hero who killed a notorious Cardassian officer after a long struggle. The real story is that Nalas had a lucky shot and the corpse happened to fall on him. Nalas didn't even know who the Cardassian was until afterwards. Despite this, he became a legend and many victories were attributed to him. Eventually he had to run away to exile to get away from the hassles of his fame.

Changed line(s) 68 (click to see context) from:

* ''Podcast/TheMistholmeMuseumOfMysteryMorbidityAndMortality'': PlayedWith in "FINAL". One of the exhibits at the [[MuseumOfTheStrangeAndUnusual titular museum]] is a rundown red Editor Pencil, which the [[BenevolentAI Tour Guide]] reveals belonged to the deceased major media tycoon and Titan of Industry Yiding Lu, who seemingly rose out of nowhere to become one of the most powerful and successful media moguls in the world. As the Guide reveals, it was only after Lu's death that it was discovered he actually started off as a very shy and timid Newspaper editor in his home town, who whilst doing a therapy exercise recommended to give him more confidence, discovered that if he rewrote events he had been through he had the power to [[MassHypnosis manipulate everyone's memories]] into believing the more preferable events were what occurred. After much trial and error, Lu seized upon this newfound power, building himself a glorious media empire. However, at the climax the guide points out that whilst this ability certainly gave him a massive advantage, all the evidence suggests that even without it Lu was a legitimately brilliant businessman, leading it to speculate that he might have managed to become successful all on his own and that the real advantage his power gave him was granting him the confidence to try, [[AmbiguousSituation or maybe that is just something else he wrote down somewhere]] that they haven't found yet.

* ''Podcast/TheMistholmeMuseumOfMysteryMorbidityAndMortality'': PlayedWith in "FINAL". One of the exhibits at the [[MuseumOfTheStrangeAndUnusual titular museum]] is a rundown red Editor Pencil, which the [[BenevolentAI Tour Guide]] reveals belonged to the deceased major media tycoon and Titan of Industry Yiding Lu, who seemingly rose out of nowhere to become one of the most powerful and successful media moguls in the world. As the Guide reveals, it was only after Lu's death that it was discovered he actually started off as a very shy and timid Newspaper editor in his home town, who whilst doing a therapy exercise recommended to give him more confidence, discovered that if he rewrote events he had been through he had the power to [[MassHypnosis manipulate everyone's memories]] into believing the more preferable events were what occurred. After much trial and error, Lu seized upon this newfound power, building himself a glorious media empire. However, at the climax the guide points out that whilst this ability certainly gave him a massive advantage, all the evidence suggests that even without it Lu was a legitimately brilliant businessman, leading it to speculate that he might have managed to become successful all on his own and that the real advantage his power gave him was granting him the confidence to try, [[AmbiguousSituation or maybe that is just something else he wrote down somewhere]] that they haven't found yet.

Changed line(s) 87 (click to see context) from:

* ''VideoGame/AceCombat7SkiesUnknown'': [[TheNeidermeyer Colonel McKinsey]] unintentionally does this to himself. He leads the Spare Squadron penal unit from a prison disguised as an airbase, and hoards all of their accomplishments for himself in the hopes that he'll be transferred over to a [[DeskJockey desk job]] far away from the frontlines. Instead, Osea High Command sends him ''directly'' to the frontlines, because they find him to be the right man to lead against Erusea thanks to his "accomplishments".

* ''VideoGame/AceCombat7SkiesUnknown'': [[TheNeidermeyer Colonel McKinsey]] unintentionally does this to himself. He leads the Spare Squadron penal unit from a prison disguised as an airbase, and hoards all of their accomplishments for himself in the hopes that he'll be transferred over to a [[DeskJockey desk job]] far away from the frontlines. Instead, Osea High Command sends him ''directly'' to the frontlines, because they find him to be the right man to lead against Erusea thanks to his "accomplishments".

Changed line(s) 89 (click to see context) from:

%%* ''VideoGame/IHaveNoMouthAndIMustScream'': Ted is a con artist. He's been anything he needed to when he wanted something from someone, be it affection, money or possessions. He was raised in poverty with [[MassiveNumberedSiblings several siblings]], and decided he wanted more. %% How is this a Self-Made Lie. This is just him being a con artist.

%%* ''VideoGame/IHaveNoMouthAndIMustScream'': Ted is a con artist. He's been anything he needed to when he wanted something from someone, be it affection, money or possessions. He was raised in poverty with [[MassiveNumberedSiblings several siblings]], and decided he wanted more. %% How is this a Self-Made Lie. This is just him being a con artist.

Changed line(s) 98 (click to see context) from:

* ''WesternAnimation/CampLazlo'': In one episode, Edward wears a sash of fake badges to show himself to be the best Bean Scout in Camp Kidney. For this reason Commander Hoo-Ha decides to send him to Tomato Camp, but when Edward sees a video showing how ruthless Tomato Camp is, he tries to find a way to prevent him from going. He can't reveal the truth, because then Hoo-Ha would send him to Skull Crush camp as punishment. Fortunately, Edward is able to avoid Tomato Camp when he cries at the other Bean Scouts' farewell gift, because according to Hoo-Ha, [[RealMenDontCry Tomato Scouts don't cry]].

* ''WesternAnimation/CampLazlo'': In one episode, Edward wears a sash of fake badges to show himself to be the best Bean Scout in Camp Kidney. For this reason Commander Hoo-Ha decides to send him to Tomato Camp, but when Edward sees a video showing how ruthless Tomato Camp is, he tries to find a way to prevent him from going. He can't reveal the truth, because then Hoo-Ha would send him to Skull Crush camp as punishment. Fortunately, Edward is able to avoid Tomato Camp when he cries at the other Bean Scouts' farewell gift, because according to Hoo-Ha, [[RealMenDontCry Tomato Scouts don't cry]].